The Other Cheek
Many of us struggle Jesus' saying about turning the other cheek, and how it fits with the phrase "eye for eye, and tooth for tooth." Although to us it sounds barbaric, in Jesus' time however, this law was always interpreted as a monetary fine for bodily injury - never injuring the offender in return.1 They understood the idea of "eye for eye" as meaning that the fine for injuring another exactly compensated the victim for all of his or her losses. The rabbis had set up a system of five kinds of monetary damages for injuring others: for permanent impairment, for temporary incapacity, for healing expenses, for pain and for shaming.
One scholar believes that Jesus is referring to this system of fines in the passage above, and the laws about shaming a person by slapping him on the face.2 The offense of slapping someone was often a subject of discussion of the "eye for eye" laws because it did not actually cause any lasting injury - just momentary pain and embarrassment. But nevertheless, the shame that it caused was a major offense in that culture, because one's honor was extremely important in that time. So there was a fine that could be demanded of another for being shamed in this way:
The fact that a fine is involved makes the idea of "turning the other cheek" fit with the next statement about letting someone sue you too. It appears then, that Jesus was saying that rather than insisting on compensation down to the last penny for every insult, his followers should be ready to suffer persecution yet again. It also fits with Jesus' many teachings about not seeking one's own honor.
Regarding the idea of demanding compensation for shaming, Paul says something very similar:
In looking past sin and forgiving others, we are showing people the love of Christ through our own actions. We are being true disciples when we imitate our rabbi Jesus, who died for the sins of those who hated him.
©2006 Lois A. Tverberg, Ph.D., OurRabbiJesus.com. All rights
reserved. This article is copyrighted and may not be redistributed
without the express written consent of the author. To request
permission for use, contact Tverberg@OurRabbiJesus.com.